Recent Entries Friends Archive User Info Tags Jeamland
 
 
 
 
 
 
Those who follow [info]grahamsleight on Twitter will already be aware of this, but: he took a tumble while getting off his train this morning, and his broken his leg. He's now in ward T1 at University College Hospital (first floor, and -- use this information wisely -- bedside phone number apparently 07081 396234), where he is likely to be staying for a couple of days. He reports that visitors are very welcome, except between noon and 2pm. His iPhone battery is low, but so far as I can tell his spirits are good, considering.

EDIT: Further update here.
 
 
 
 
 
 
Poll #1467130
Open to: All, detailed results viewable to: All, participants: 59

New Doctor Who logo

View Answers

GOOD
28 (50.9%)

BAD
27 (49.1%)

Blackberries

View Answers

GOOD
48 (81.4%)

BAD
11 (18.6%)

Raising the retirement age

View Answers

GOOD
29 (52.7%)

BAD
26 (47.3%)

This year's Booker shortlist

View Answers

GOOD
22 (48.9%)

BAD
23 (51.1%)

Google Wave

View Answers

GOOD
28 (63.6%)

BAD
16 (36.4%)

Quiche

View Answers

GOOD
39 (67.2%)

BAD
19 (32.8%)

Octocon

View Answers

GOOD
12 (28.6%)

BAD
30 (71.4%)

Doing a GOOD or BAD poll while [info]ninebelow is away and cannot participate

View Answers

GOOD
28 (54.9%)

BAD
23 (45.1%)

New FTC guidelines on blogging

View Answers

GOOD
9 (19.1%)

BAD
38 (80.9%)

A new regime of early starts

View Answers

GOOD
24 (43.6%)

BAD
31 (56.4%)

Michael Tomasky

View Answers

GOOD
14 (40.0%)

BAD
21 (60.0%)

Stargate Universe

View Answers

GOOD
14 (31.1%)

BAD
31 (68.9%)

Glee

View Answers

GOOD
33 (68.8%)

BAD
15 (31.2%)

This

View Answers

GOOD
22 (50.0%)

BAD
22 (50.0%)

The thing that Niall meant to put in this poll but forgot

View Answers

GOOD
34 (60.7%)

BAD
22 (39.3%)

 
 
 
 
 
 
An extraordinary novel in many ways, one of which is the way in which I think this, from Rosemary Ashton's introduction to the current Penguin Classic edition, is dead wrong:
We have seen that Lydgate's own ideal of womanhood is damagingly limited and egotistical. So too is Casaubon's ... Yet there is some authorial ambivalence here. Just as, while criticizing Lydate's expectations of a wife, George Eliot seems also to blame Rosamond for not putting her husband's view and needs before her own, so with Dorothea she moves between sharp satire of Mr Casaubon's requirement of complete devotion in a wife and warm authorial endorsement of Dorothea's desire to serve her husband selflessly. (xvii)

I don't think there is any ambivalence here: all are being judged by the same criteria, which is the extent to which they are able to enter imaginatively into other's lives. Lydgate, Casaubon and Rosamond are criticized for (in different ways) failing to do so, or doing so only to a limited extent; Dorothea is praised because she does so, even though it is in many cases to excess.

The great strength of the book, of course, is the astonishingly generous omniscient voice in which it is told, which has time for every character's particular desires, and (though it chides) has sympathy with every one of its inhabitants. More people, I want to say, should write omniscient voice like this, and this well. The voice enables some of the things I enjoyed most about the novel -- its wit, and its social acuity -- things which, it strikes me, are what Jane Austen fans say they get from her writing, but which I have never been able to find there. For me, in fact, the voice was often the most compelling thing about the book; Ashton is right that
[Ladislaw] is the least successfully imagined character in the novel, partly because he is obliged by e plot to be rootless and have mysterious origins, and to function as a handsome, youthful foil to his fading older cousin Casaubon. (xv)

-- with the result that his relationship with Dorothea is supremely unconvincing (if entirely predictable; I'm a little astonished that Jo Walton can write "I defy anyone to guess what’s going to happen in Middlemarch, even from half way through", because it's blindingly obvious that Dorothea is going to end up in a suitable marriage at the end of the book, it being unthinkable that she might live happily as an independent; the only questions are ones of detail, exactly how the marriage is going to happen), although he's not the least interesting character: that would be Bulstrode, most of whose chapters nearly put me to sleep.

I wonder whether that voice isn't ultimately a vice disguised as a virtue, in some ways; its message is -- quite rightly -- that we can never know the full circumstances of anything, never know another person entirely, but its existence undermines that message. Makes it a bit too comfortable. Although this was never a book where I sank through the page. I think that was in part because for all the precise delineation of the various relationships -- Rosamond and Lydgate's marriage is the best, because it would have been so easy to make one or other of them unambiguously the villain; this is where the narrator's limitless sympathy and empathy are most admirable, and the hard edge to their ending feels right -- the geography of the setting was more than a little vague. Every time I thought I'd worked out where one place was in relation to another, I would be (it seemed) contradicted, and my inhabitance of the book disturbed. Yes, reader, I wanted a map!

But it's a book I will probably return to in five or ten years, nevertheless.
 
 
 
 
 
 
Testing a mobile LJ client...
 
 
 
 
 
 
For those who missed it last night: the 2009 Arthur C Clarke Award shortlist.
 
 
 
 
 
 
At the weekend, concern was expressed that I hadn't run a GOOD or BAD poll for a while. There was a fear that people might have gotten out of the habit of making arbitrary judgements. Hence: a new year treat for you all! Don't think, just click.

Poll #1325707
Open to: All, detailed results viewable to: All, participants: 85

Bringing your own tankard to a party

View Answers

GOOD!
50 (61.0%)

BAD!
32 (39.0%)

Heritage beards

View Answers

GOOD!
35 (42.2%)

BAD!
48 (57.8%)

Needing to fill out a form to apply for a form

View Answers

GOOD!
3 (3.5%)

BAD!
82 (96.5%)

Mathcore

View Answers

GOOD!
36 (47.4%)

BAD!
40 (52.6%)

New Shoe Rock

View Answers

GOOD!
25 (33.3%)

BAD!
50 (66.7%)

"Xakus's kicking feet disappeared. The lips of the vegetative tube squelched shut. Jelly glistened. The flaps quivered like an epileptic vulva".

View Answers

GOOD!
12 (14.6%)

BAD!
70 (85.4%)

German sausage coated with so much pepper it makes your taste buds explode

View Answers

GOOD!
54 (64.3%)

BAD!
30 (35.7%)

Spaghetti Hoops

View Answers

GOOD!
37 (45.1%)

BAD!
45 (54.9%)

Final Fantasy XII

View Answers

GOOD!
25 (33.3%)

BAD!
50 (66.7%)

End-of-year lists

View Answers

GOOD!
58 (69.9%)

BAD!
25 (30.1%)

Naming bands after Italian restaurants

View Answers

GOOD!
23 (27.7%)

BAD!
60 (72.3%)

The '90s being almost two decades ago

View Answers

GOOD!
23 (27.1%)

BAD!
62 (72.9%)

Fibreoptic Christmas trees

View Answers

GOOD!
38 (45.8%)

BAD!
45 (54.2%)

Pride & Prejudice

View Answers

GOOD!
65 (78.3%)

BAD!
18 (21.7%)

CHEEEESE

View Answers

GOOD!
77 (91.7%)

BAD!
7 (8.3%)

 
 
 
 
 
 
But for this, I will make an exception.

 
 
 
 
 
 
Poll #1229576
Open to: All, detailed results viewable to: All, participants: 80

Neal Stephenson

View Answers

GOOD
67 (83.8%)

BAD
13 (16.2%)

 
 
 
 
 
 
Following on from a mutually surprising discussion last weekend:

Poll #1229575
Open to: All, detailed results viewable to: All, participants: 70

What is Neal Stephenson's best book?

View Answers

The Big U
0 (0.0%)

Zodiac
6 (8.6%)

Snow Crash
20 (28.6%)

Interface
0 (0.0%)

The Diamond Age
13 (18.6%)

Cobweb
0 (0.0%)

Cryptonomicon
21 (30.0%)

Quicksilver
5 (7.1%)

The Confusion
0 (0.0%)

The System of the World
3 (4.3%)

In the Beginning was the Command Line
2 (2.9%)

Anathem
0 (0.0%)

What is Neal Stephenson's worst book?

View Answers

The Big U
15 (25.9%)

Zodiac
7 (12.1%)

Snow Crash
1 (1.7%)

Interface
4 (6.9%)

The Diamond Age
7 (12.1%)

Cobweb
3 (5.2%)

Cryptonomicon
8 (13.8%)

Quicksilver
5 (8.6%)

The Confusion
2 (3.4%)

The System of the World
6 (10.3%)

In the Beginning was the Command Line
0 (0.0%)

Anathem
0 (0.0%)



Justification in the comments welcomed.
 
 
 
 
 
 
To be clear: I have not watched "Journey's End" yet, because [info]bibliolicious is out at a gig this evening. But I wouldn't wish to deprive anyone of poll-clicking fun, and anyway I'm planning to pretty much avoid the internet for the next 24 hours, so:

Poll #1218259
Open to: All, detailed results viewable to: All, participants: 41

Partners in Crime

View Answers

GOOD!
21 (55.3%)

BAD!
17 (44.7%)

The Fires of Pompeii

View Answers

GOOD!
35 (87.5%)

BAD!
5 (12.5%)

Planet of the Ood

View Answers

GOOD!
28 (71.8%)

BAD!
11 (28.2%)

The Sontaran Stratagem

View Answers

GOOD!
25 (65.8%)

BAD!
13 (34.2%)

The Poison Sky

View Answers

GOOD!
18 (47.4%)

BAD!
20 (52.6%)

The Doctor's Daughter

View Answers

GOOD!
17 (44.7%)

BAD!
21 (55.3%)

The Unicorn and the Wasp

View Answers

GOOD!
25 (67.6%)

BAD!
12 (32.4%)

Silence in the Library

View Answers

GOOD!
37 (94.9%)

BAD!
2 (5.1%)

Forest of the Dead

View Answers

GOOD!
31 (81.6%)

BAD!
7 (18.4%)

Midnight

View Answers

GOOD!
29 (80.6%)

BAD!
7 (19.4%)

Turn Left

View Answers

GOOD!
32 (88.9%)

BAD!
4 (11.1%)

The Stolen Earth

View Answers

GOOD!
28 (75.7%)

BAD!
9 (24.3%)

Journey's End

View Answers

GOOD!
21 (60.0%)

BAD!
14 (40.0%)

Season 4 overall?

View Answers

GOOD!
29 (78.4%)

BAD!
8 (21.6%)

Best season?

View Answers

SEASON ONE!
14 (36.8%)

SEASON TWO!
1 (2.6%)

SEASON THREE!
11 (28.9%)

SEASON FOUR!
12 (31.6%)



Feel free to link to your Who posts in the comments. Actually, that would be really helpful, because by the time I get around to watching the episode any relevant posts will probably be buried at about skip=300, and thus difficult to find.